MADRID – The return to Santiago Bernabéu after a month's absence was supposed to be a celebration. It turned into a complete nightmare for Real Madrid, severely beaten 2-0 by Celta Vigo, a modest 15th in the standings, this Sunday, December 7, 2025. This defeat, much more than a simple sporting setback, paints the picture of a team completely lost, psychologically fragile, and collectively nonexistent, widening a worrying four-point gap behind its rival, FC Barcelona.
A Tactical and Mental Debacle
From the very first minutes, the scenario went awry. Trailing 1-0 at the start of the second half, after a sumptuous goal from Williot Swedberg, the Merengues never found the key to trouble a perfectly organized Celta defense. As opposing striker Borja Iglesias unsparingly summarized, the Madrilenians “gave up far too early.” The match then turned into a total fiasco with two expulsions in the second half: first left-back Fran Garcia, then his replacement Alvaro Carreras, both guilty of desperate acts of frustration. The humiliation was completed by a red card given to Endrick… from the substitutes' bench, a symptom of widespread frustration.
A historic rout because Real had not lost by two goals at the Bernabéu since May 2019 (excluding Clásico), and is considered by many sports commentators to be the culmination of a dark streak: only one victory in the last five La Liga matches.
Individual statistics are just as damning. Vinicius Jr, for example, finished the match with 0 goals, 0 assists, 0 chances created, and only 25% shooting accuracy, a phantom performance that summarizes the attack's ineffectiveness.
The Glaring Lack of Identity Under Xabi Alonso
Beyond the result, it's the style of play that is alarming. As sports journalist Ralph Ganthier so aptly analyzes, “After 6 months at the helm of this team, Xabi [Alonso] still doesn't have a typical starting eleven or a distinct identity.” The assessment is harsh but reflects an observable reality on the field: the team seems to be a collection of individual talents without coherence.
Real Madrid's current success relies almost exclusively on the solitary exploits of Kylian Mbappé, whose pursuit of the top scorer title (Pichichi) sometimes seems to overshadow the team's needs. “It's as if Real had set up a project to make Mbappé the Pichichi and the Golden Boot,” Ganthier continues, pointing to a potential imbalance in sporting priorities.
The defense, in disarray, paid the price for this disorganization. Worse still, Real Madrid has likely lost its Brazilian central defender Éder Militão for an estimated three months, another catastrophe in an already fragile sector.
Immediate Consequences for the Madrilenians
Multiple and serious consequences stem from this humiliation:
- Sportingly, Real (2nd) sees Barcelona pull ahead at the top. Worse, if Villarreal wins its postponed match, Real could be relegated to third place, an inconceivable situation in November.
- Psychologically, the team showed a worrying face of mental fragility. The consecutive expulsions of Garcia and Carreras, as well as the numerous yellow cards distributed (Bellingham, Valverde, Rodrygo, coach Xabi Alonso himself), betray a group on edge, unable to manage pressure and frustration.
- Strategically, the pressure on Xabi Alonso's shoulders intensifies. The architect of a brilliant Bayer Leverkusen still seems to be searching for his model in Madrid. The absence of an identifiable playing style and excessive reliance on individuality raise questions about his ability to build a balanced team capable of competing on all fronts.
Against Celta Vigo, Real Madrid didn't just lose three points. They lost their aura, their home solidity, and, above all, the sense of control that usually characterizes them in difficult moments.
The “cold shower” mentioned by supporters is actually a tsunami revealing the cracks in a precarious construction project. The rallying cry of French sports journalist Loguito, “THE HUMILIATION IS TOTAL,” sounds like an electroshock.
The coming week, before the next league match and as the crucial Champions League phases approach, will be decisive for Xabi Alonso. He must imperatively redefine a playing identity, restore defensive solidarity, and rediscover the warrior mentality that built the club's greatness. Otherwise, this defeat against Celta will not just be an accident, but the symptom of a season that could go very wrong.